Home / Journal / Coffee Science

Is Decaf Coffee Any Good? How Sugarcane Decaf Works

Decaf has a reputation problem. For a lot of people it means a flat, papery cup.

That reputation was earned by stale beans and blunt processes, not by decaf itself. Good decaf, made from good beans with a gentle process and brewed with care, tastes like coffee, because it is.

This post covers how decaf is made, what “sugarcane decaf” means, and why we pour one we're proud of, especially at 2 a.m.

How do you take caffeine out of coffee?

All decaf starts the same way: green, unroasted beans are soaked or steamed to open them up, then something draws out the caffeine while leaving the flavour compounds behind. The beans are dried and roasted later like any other coffee.

The main methods differ in what does the drawing out:

  • Swiss Water Process. Water and carbon filters, with no added solvent.
  • CO₂ process. Pressurized carbon dioxide dissolves the caffeine. Common for large volumes.
  • Methylene chloride. An effective solvent process, and the one that gave decaf its chemical reputation.
  • Ethyl acetate (EA), or sugarcane decaf. Uses a compound made from fermented sugarcane.

What is sugarcane decaf?

Ethyl acetate occurs naturally in ripe fruit and wine. For decaf, it's produced by fermenting sugarcane, which is plentiful in coffee-growing countries like Colombia. That's why the method is called sugarcane decaf, or sugarcane-derived EA decaf.

The process, roughly:

  1. Green beans are steamed to swell them and open their pores.
  2. They're washed in water mixed with sugarcane-derived ethyl acetate, which dissolves the caffeine.
  3. The solution is drained, and the wash is repeated until the beans are decaffeinated.
  4. The beans are steamed again to remove remaining ethyl acetate, then dried.

It's a gentle process, usually run close to where the coffee is grown, and it tends to keep a coffee's sweetness. Sugarcane decafs are often described as having a soft, fruity, brown-sugar character.

Our decaf: De Mello's Zumachi

Our decaf is Zumachi, from Toronto specialty roaster De Mello. It's a Castillo coffee grown at 2,100 metres in Huila, Colombia, one of the country's most celebrated coffee regions, and decaffeinated right there in Colombia with the sugarcane process.

In the cup: brown sugar, raspberry jam and orange. It's a lovely coffee in its own right, it holds up beautifully with milk, and any espresso drink on our menu can be made with it.

Is decaf caffeine-free?

Not completely, and it's worth knowing. Decaffeination removes almost all of the caffeine, and Canadian food rules cap how much can remain in coffee sold as decaf. A decaf drink still has a few milligrams, a small fraction of a regular cup. That's not nothing if you're very sensitive, but it won't keep most people up at night.

Why most decaf tastes bad

  • Old beans. Decaf sells slowly, so in many cafés it goes stale. Freshness matters even more for decaf, because the process leaves beans a little more porous.
  • Afterthought sourcing. Cheap decaf is often made from beans no one wanted as regular coffee. Good decaf starts with good coffee.
  • Afterthought brewing. Decaf extracts a little differently from regular coffee. Treat it as second-class and it'll taste that way.

At Caffeo, decaf gets its own master-barista recipe, held to the same precision as everything else: a dose weighed to a tenth of a gram and a controlled extraction, every time.

When decaf makes sense

  • Late at night. We're open 24/7, and decaf is how you enjoy a 1 a.m. coffee and still sleep.
  • Your third coffee of the day, when you want the ritual but not more caffeine.
  • Pregnancy or medical advice to cut back. Check with your doctor about what's right for you.
  • Caffeine sensitivity, if regular coffee makes you jittery.

Good decaf isn't a lesser coffee. It's coffee for a different time of day. Try it at 405 Richmond St. W, any hour you like.

Good Coffee, Any Hour.

Join the Caffeo List for new drinks, giveaways and early access to Caffeo Rewards. One or two emails a month.